Jobs was able to use his own personal magnetism to direct your attention at the lovely gadget he held in his hands. Without a personality like that to focus on, Apple fans will have nothing to react to but the product.
So, the success of Apple so far was due solely Steve’s charisma? That’s a little shortsighted.
If that’s what Lance is saying, it’s irresponsible.
If that’s not what he was saying, that’s a poor choice of words.
Sure, Steve Jobs was the face of Apple. Apple’s success was largely due to his vision, but to make a statement like that, seemingly implying that even bad products would be seen as success simply because Steve Jobs was presenting them is irresponsible.
Does anyone think that Apple’s success is owed to anything other than making amazing products?
There is danger for any business if they tie themselves to any one person to closely. Certainly, Apple was tied to Steve Jobs – that’s undeniable. But to say that their success is so tied to that one man that he could enchant people enough to buy Apple products even if they didn’t stand up to critique is ridiculous.
In fairness, Ulanoff does say that he “directed your attention at the lovely gadget that he held in his hands.” But saying that Apple fans will now be forced to react to the product alone (in my mind) implies that people didn’t focus on the product before because they were hypnotized by the show that Steve put on.
Did people love the polish of a Steve Jobs keynote? Absolutely.
Was Steve the biggest champion and evangelist for Apple products? You bet.
Were Apple products widely adopted because of Steve’s chrisma? Doubtful.
There are many extremely intelligent people using Apple products and I struggle to think that they were duped into using them. If the products didn’t hold up to Steve’s hype, there’s no doubt that they wouldn’t have been as successful as they are.
The lesson here is that a charismatic leader can provide a jump start for a company, but the product they are promoting must stand on its own if it is going to be successful.
I think that we can confidently say that the iPad 3 and many Apple products to come will do just that.



